Supreme Court 3JX Final Orders

3JX FINAL ORDERS

Final orders issued by the Supreme Court in cases heard by the three-judge panel appeal process known as 3JX will be made available on a regular basis on the Supreme Court web site beginning with final 3JX orders issued on or after September 1, 2004.  Only final orders issued in 3JX cases will be published; orders in 3JX cases that are not final orders, such as an order remanding to the trial court for clarification, will not be published.

The court has authorized the publication of 3JX orders for informational purposes only.  Readers should be aware that Supreme Court Rule 12-D(3) states that a 3JX order has no precedential value.  It provides: 

An order issued by a 3JX panel shall have no precedential value and shall not be cited in any pleadings or rulings in any court in this state; provided, however, that such order may be cited and shall be controlling with respect to issues of claim preclusion, law of the case and similar issues involving the parties or facts of the case in which the order was issued.

December 26, 2006

• 2005-0826, David B. Tuttle Trustee U/A dated June 1, 1971 v. Nicholas B. Cohen

December 22, 2006

• 2005-0893, In the Matter of Catherine Gilman and George Gilman, III

December 7, 2006

• 2005-0805, Town of Hudson v. James F. Kelly, Sr.

December 5, 2006

• 2006-0103, State of New Hampshire v. Michael Caico
• 2006-0093, Appeal of Gale Cossette

November 28, 2006

• 2006-0132, State of New Hampshire v. Thomas P. Hersey

• 2006-0349, Petition of Jeffrey G.

November 16, 2006

• 2005-0897, Thomas A. Methvin v. Gunstock Area Commission

November 3, 2006

• 2005-0667, Brad W. Wilder v. Town of Plainfield

• 2005-0811, In re Juvenile 2005-0811

October 19, 2006

• 2005-0723, Ronald Stafford & a. v. Lucille A. Shea, Trustee

October 17, 2006

• 2005-0764, Tracy Middleton, Trustee of Tracy J. Middleton Revocable Trust & a. v. Town of Greenland

• 2005-0565, MDR Corporation v. Anthony Scappicio, James Mower and Mary Mower

October 16, 2006

• 2005-0713, In the Matter of Pamela Domigan and John Wall

October 12, 2006

• 2005-0768, Appeal of New Generation Construction, LLC

October 2, 2006

• 2005-0653, Marjan International Corp. v. Mohammad Enayat d/b/a Sutter and Hayes Rug Outlet

September 21, 2006

• 2005-0574, Norma Kolifrath v. Joan Romboli & a.

• 2005-0641, Sean Croft v. Commissioner, New Hampshire Department of Corrections

• 2005-0480, The Cadle Company v. Maurice Bourgeois & a.

September 20, 2006

• 2005-0712, In the Matter of Cynthia Vocell-Henderson and James J. Vocell

September 14, 2006

• 2005-0497, In the Matter of Lee G. Clow and Frederick J. Clow

• 2005-0311, In the Matter of Narotam S. Grewal and Gail E. Garrison

• 2005-0566, In the Matter of Linda A. Plaisted (now Manning) and Grahame J. Plaisted

• 2005-0541, State of New Hampshire v. Frank Staples

September 11, 2006

• 2005-0413, State of New Hampshire v. Joseph Bissonnette, Jr.

• 2005-0554, Jonathan Wolfgram v. Vermont Mutual Insurance Company

September 1, 2006

• 2004-0882, State of New Hampshire v. Anthony Johnson

August 22, 2006

• 2005-0080, State of New Hampshire v. Jeremy D. Paradis

August 16, 2006

• 2005-0317, In the Matter of Eileen E. Boulanger and Paul W. Boulanger, Jr.

• 2005-0397, Renee Powers v. LAM Brothers d/b/a Dynasty Chinese Restaurant

• 2005-0433, Craig W. Roche v. Virginia O'Neil, Trustee of Virginia O'Neil Revocable Trust

• 2005-0438, State Farm Mutual Insurance Co. v. Sara Bigelson

August 11, 2006

• 2005-0228, State of New Hampshire v. Roland Chretien

August 10, 2006

• 2005-0603, Center Capital Construction v. Barnaby's Truck & Equipment, Inc. & a.; Center Capital Construction v. Rome Construction, Inc. & a.

• 2005-0610, Insurance Commissioner as Liquidator of the Home Insurance Company v. Utica Mutual Insurance Company

July 28, 2006

• 2005-0744, Appeal of Robert Steele d/b/a Hampshire Pewter & a.

July 25, 2006

• 2005-0233, Rochester Motorsports, Inc. & a. v. Leighton's Kawasaki, Inc. & a.; Paul Hurlbert v. Leighton's Kawasaki, Inc. & a.

• 2005-0309, State of New Hampshire v. Christopher K. Cayer

July 12, 2006

• 2005-0420, State of New Hampshire v. Martin Mullen

July 13, 2006

• 2005-0270, Ralph Cosseboom & a. v. Town of Cornish

June 29, 2006

• 2004-0350, State of New Hampshire v. Paula Reichey

June 8, 2006

• 2005-0468, Jerry L. Rich v. Town of Enfield, Donald E. Roberts, Evelyn P. Patten

• 2005-0321, Tracey Bascio v. CorVel Healthcare Corporation

• 2005-0037, Julio Sanchez v. Daher Auto Trade, Inc. & a.

June 7, 2006

• 2005-0164, State of New Hampshire v. Rodney Martinez

May 31, 2006

• 2005-0377, Physicians Dialysis, Inc. v. David R. Haight

May 23, 2006

• 2004-0360, In the Matter of Lisa M. Martin and James A. Martin

May 19, 2006

• 2005-0141, Little Island Pond Watershed Association & a. v. Town of Pelham

May 18, 2006

• 2005-0339, Joseph E. Sullivan, III v. Town of Conway, ZBA

May 11, 2006

• 2005-0281, In the Matter of John P. Griffith and Joan H. Griffith

April 26, 2006

• 2005-0178, David West v. Salomon, Randlett & Bernard & a.

• 2005-0393, In the Matter of Anne E. Carano and Jeffrey L. Carano

April 21, 2006

• 2005-0159, William E. Evans & a. v. Stonefence Acquisitions, LLC & a.

• 2004-0739, State of New Hampshire v. Robert Bartlett

April 17, 2006

• 2005-0053, Van E. Hertel, Sr., Trustee of The Raed Hertel Family Trust, U/D/O 1/191 v. Universal Grace Church

• 2005-0181, State of New Hampshire v. Moise William

• 2005-0284, State of New Hampshire v. Stephan A. Huntoon

April 6, 2006

• 2005-0175, State of New Hampshire v. William Parks

March 31, 2006

• 2005-0390, Appeal of Michael P. Robarge

March 23, 2006

• 2005-0104, State of New Hampshire v. Brian R. Chevalier

• 2004-0860, State of New Hampshire v. Harlan Searles

March 16, 2006

• 2005-0210, Rowell Real Estate Investment Trust v. Town of Kingston

March 14, 2006

• 2005-0027, Thomas A. Mason v. Walter Henry Shaw, III & a.

March 7, 2006

• 2005-0043, Kathleen M. Keenan, Trustee, Guckert New Hampshire Realty Trust v. Ossipee Realty Corporation & a.

• 2005-0086, PC Production Temps, Inc. v. Abatement International/Advatex Associates, Inc.

March 3, 2006

• 2005-0124, Lawrence W. Cleasby v. Phoenix Auto Body, Inc.; Lawrence Cleasby v. Phoenix Auto Body, Inc.

• 2004-0782, Financial Resources and Assistance of the Lakes Region v. National Inspection and Repair Co., Inc. & a.

February 27, 2006

• 2004-0596, State of New Hampshire v. Paul Moreau
• 2005-0088, Appeal of I.C. Reed & Sons, Inc.

February 24, 2006

• 2004-0563, Pool Environments, Inc. v. Peter Holden
• 2004-0587, State of New Hampshire v. David S. Hill

February 23, 2006

• 2005-0117, State of New Hampshire v. Alan S. Lighthall

February 22, 2006

• 2005-0129, State of New Hampshire v. Felix Lopez

February 21, 2006

• 2005-0096, In the Matter of Catherine Chavolla and Jose Chavolla

February 16, 2006

• 2004-0644, State of New Hampshire v. Joseph Barden
• 2004-0872, Springhaven Campground, LLC v. Howard E. Pennock, Individually and as Trustee of the Howard E. Pennock Revocable Trust and Judith Pennock, Individually and as Trustee of the Judith Pennock Revocable Trust

February 13, 2006

• 2005-0016, State of New Hampshire v. Kenneth W. Allder

February 6, 2006

• 2005-0231, State of New Hampshire v. Wendy Wolfson
• 2004-0613, State of New Hampshire v. Mark Demita

January 26, 2006

• 2005-0083, State of New Hampshire v. Richard E. Hebbard
• 2005-0113, Brian Bilodeau & a. v. Town of Sandwich, ZBA

January 20, 2006

• 2005-0007, Samuel Zannini, Jr. v. Town of Atkinson

January 9, 2006

• 2004-0590, State of New Hampshire v. Elvis Burke