THE STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE PAGE 1 DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PROJECT: STATEWIDE 15709 COUNTIES AND CODES: VARIES DATE BIDS OPEN: MAY 20, 2010 SCOPE OF WORK: GUARDRAIL REPLACEMENT LOCATION: SEE THE PROSECUTION OF WORK COMPLETION DATE: OCTOBER 15, 2010 A DELUCCA FENCE COMPANY, INC. FIVE OLD FERRY ROAD, METHUEN, MA 01844 $ 1,287,590.33 B CWS FENCE & GUARDRAIL 261 FRANKLIN HWY., ANDOVER, NH 03216 $ 1,456,411.75 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ITEM A B NO. DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY UNIT PRICE TOTAL UNIT PRICE TOTAL UNIT PRICE TOTAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 202.701 REMOVAL OF GUARDRAIL LF 43,250. .83 35,897.50 2.00 86,500.00 203.1 COMMON EXCAVATION CY 40. 61.95 2,478.00 25.00 1,000.00 203.5554 GUARDRAIL 50' EAGRT PLATFORM U 29. 977.00 28,333.00 900.00 26,100.00 206.19 COMMON STRUCTURE EXCAVATION EXPLORATORY CY 75. 28.00 2,100.00 10.00 750.00 304.301 CRUSHED GRAVEL CY 32. 29.40 940.80 45.00 1,440.00 304.32 CRUSHED GRAVEL FOR SHOULDER LEVELING TON 140. 33.60 4,704.00 30.00 4,200.00 403.12 HOT BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT, HAND METHOD TON 90. 183.75 16,537.50 245.00 22,050.00 550.101 STRUCTURAL STEEL (F) LB 2,000. 8.69 17,380.00 8.70 17,400.00 550.102 STRUCTURAL STEEL (F) LB 575. 9.08 5,221.00 10.75 6,181.25 565.802 ADJUSTING BRIDGE APPROACH RAIL U 3. 333.00 999.00 250.00 750.00 565.91 BRIDGE APPROACH RAIL, THRIE BEAM TRANSITION (STEEL POSTS) U 2. 2,444.00 4,888.00 2,895.00 5,790.00 565.92 BRIDGE APPROACH RAIL, ASYMMETRICAL THRIE BEAM TRANSITION (STEEL POSTS) U 10. 2,383.00 23,830.00 3,000.00 30,000.00 585.3 STONE FILL, CLASS C CY 55. 43.58 2,396.90 60.00 3,300.00 604.0007 POLYETHYLENE LINER EA 8. 262.50 2,100.00 200.00 1,600.00 604.4 RECONSTRUCTING/ADJUSTING CATCH BASIN & DROP INLET LF 16. 381.50 6,104.00 100.00 1,600.00 604.71 GRATES & FRAMES, TYPE A EA 5. 393.00 1,965.00 500.00 2,500.00 606.0001 STEEL BEAM FOR BEAM GUARDRAIL, INCLUDING HARDWARE LF 68.75 11.63 799.56 8.00 550.00 606.0031 STEEL BEAM (THRIE BEAM) FOR BEAM GUARDRAIL, INCLUDING HARDWARE LF 108. 21.33 2,303.64 27.00 2,916.00 15709 PAGE 2 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ITEM A B NO. DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY UNIT PRICE TOTAL UNIT PRICE TOTAL UNIT PRICE TOTAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 606.120 BEAM GUARDRAIL (STANDARD SECTION-STEEL POST) LF 39,650. 15.58 617,747.00 14.75 584,837.50 606.12031 BEAM GUARDRAIL (THRIE BEAM-MODIFIED) INCLUDING TRANS SECT, STEEL POSTS LF 1,475. 24.14 35,606.50 24.00 35,400.00 606.12831 BEAM GUARDRAIL (THRIE BEAM APPROACH RAIL INCL. TRANSITION SECTION) U 2. 2,706.00 5,412.00 2,525.00 5,050.00 606.12851 BEAM GUARDRAIL (BRIDGE APPROACH UNIT) U 2. 4,300.00 8,600.00 2,775.00 5,550.00 606.14542 BEAM GUARDRAIL (TERM. UNIT TYPE EAGRT 50 FT., STEEL POSTS) U 29. 1,856.00 53,824.00 2,100.00 60,900.00 606.147 BEAM GUARDRAIL (TERMINAL UNIT TYPE G-2) U 29. 383.00 11,107.00 500.00 14,500.00 606.14962 BEAM GUARDRAIL (TERMINAL UNIT TYPE E-2, STEEL POSTS) LF 302. 28.64 8,649.28 30.00 9,060.00 606.2120 DOUBLE-FACED STEEL BEAM GUARDRAIL (GALVANIZED), STEEL POSTS LF 150. 29.64 4,446.00 26.50 3,975.00 606.312 SINGLE FACED TRANSITION RAIL, STEEL POSTS U 3. 2,147.00 6,441.00 2,675.00 8,025.00 606.412 CONCRETE BARRIER, DOUBLE- FACED, PRECAST LF 80. 84.00 6,720.00 100.00 8,000.00 606.41211 TRANSTION MEDIAN CONCRETE BARRIER, PRECAST U 4. 2,205.00 8,820.00 2,400.00 9,600.00 609.5 RESET GRANITE CURB LF 720. 15.77 11,354.40 13.00 9,360.00 609.811 BITUMINOUS CURB, TYPE B (4" REVEAL) LF 1,150. 6.28 7,222.00 9.20 10,580.00 618.61 UNIFORMED OFFICERS WITH VEHICLE $ 1. 75,000.00 75,000.00 75,000.00 75,000.00 619.1 MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC U 1. 16,960.00 16,960.00 55,650.00 55,650.00 619.63 TRUCK-MOUNTED IMPACT ATTENUATOR, TEST LEVEL 3 EA 1. 6,930.00 6,930.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 621.2 RETROREFLECTIVE BEAM GUARDRAIL DELINEATOR EA 500. 3.55 1,775.00 4.00 2,000.00 621.31 SINGLE DELINEATOR WITH POST EA 220. 26.00 5,720.00 30.00 6,600.00 628.2 SAWED BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT LF 1,925. 2.63 5,062.75 2.50 4,812.50 645.531 SILT FENCE LF 22,750. 2.47 56,192.50 2.00 45,500.00 646.41 TURF ESTABLISHMENT WITH MULCH, TACKIFIERS AND HUMUS SY 14,200. 4.12 58,504.00 2.00 28,400.00 678.2 IMPACT ATTENUATION DEVICE (TEST LEVEL 3) U 2. 25,658.00 51,316.00 28,245.00 56,490.00 678.201 IMPACT ATTENUATOR FOUNDATION PAD U 2. 2,363.00 4,726.00 2,000.00 4,000.00 692. MOBILIZATION U 1. 15,477.00 15,477.00 148,494.50 148,494.50 15709 PAGE 3 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ITEM A B NO. DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY UNIT PRICE TOTAL UNIT PRICE TOTAL UNIT PRICE TOTAL ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 699. MISCELLANEOUS TEMPORARY EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL $ 1. 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 1008.11 ALTERATIONS AND ADDITIONS AS NEEDED- UNANTICIPATED WORK $ 1. 15,000.00 15,000.00 15,000.00 15,000.00 1010.15 FUEL ADJUSTMENT $ 1. 20,000.00 20,000.00 20,000.00 20,000.00 $1,287,590.33 $1,456,411.75 STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION A-PS&E COMPARISION PROJECT: STATEWIDE 15709 COUNTIES AND CODES: VARIES DATE BIDS OPEN: MAY 20, 2010 SCOPE OF WORK: GUARDRAIL REPLACEMENT LOCATION: SEE THE PROSECUTION OF WORK COMPLETION DATE: OCTOBER 15, 2010 A DELUCCA FENCE COMPANY, INC. FIVE OLD FERRY ROAD, METHUEN, MA 01844 $ 1,287,590.33 B CWS FENCE & GUARDRAIL 261 FRANKLIN HWY., ANDOVER, NH 03216 $ 1,456,411.75 A-BIDDER PS&E ----------------------- ----------------------- A-PS&E ITEM NO. ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY UNIT PRICE AMOUNT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT DIFFERENCE 202.701 REMOVAL OF GUARDRAIL LF 43,250. .83 35,897.50 2.00 86,500.00 -50,602.50 203.1 COMMON EXCAVATION CY 40. 61.95 2,478.00 10.00 400.00 2,078.00 203.5554 GUARDRAIL 50' EAGRT PLATFORM U 29. 977.00 28,333.00 800.00 23,200.00 5,133.00 206.19 COMMON STRUCTURE EXCAVATION EXPLORATORY CY 75. 28.00 2,100.00 25.00 1,875.00 225.00 304.301 CRUSHED GRAVEL CY 32. 29.40 940.80 20.00 640.00 300.80 304.32 CRUSHED GRAVEL FOR SHOULDER LEVELING TON 140. 33.60 4,704.00 30.00 4,200.00 504.00 403.12 HOT BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT, HAND METHOD TON 90. 183.75 16,537.50 150.00 13,500.00 3,037.50 550.101 STRUCTURAL STEEL (F) LB 2,000. 8.69 17,380.00 5.00 10,000.00 7,380.00 550.102 STRUCTURAL STEEL (F) LB 575. 9.08 5,221.00 10.00 5,750.00 -529.00 565.802 ADJUSTING BRIDGE APPROACH RAIL U 3. 333.00 999.00 1,000.00 3,000.00 -2,001.00 565.91 BRIDGE APPROACH RAIL, THRIE BEAM TRANSITION (STEEL POSTS) U 2. 2,444.00 4,888.00 2,750.00 5,500.00 -612.00 565.92 BRIDGE APPROACH RAIL, ASYMMETRICAL THRIE BEAM TRANSITION (STEEL POSTS) U 10. 2,383.00 23,830.00 2,750.00 27,500.00 -3,670.00 585.3 STONE FILL, CLASS C CY 55. 43.58 2,396.90 35.00 1,925.00 471.90 604.0007 POLYETHYLENE LINER EA 8. 262.50 2,100.00 150.00 1,200.00 900.00 604.4 RECONSTRUCTING/ADJUSTING CATCH BASIN & DROP INLET LF 16. 381.50 6,104.00 275.00 4,400.00 1,704.00 604.71 GRATES & FRAMES, TYPE A EA 5. 393.00 1,965.00 375.00 1,875.00 90.00 606.0001 STEEL BEAM FOR BEAM GUARDRAIL, INCLUDING HARDWARE LF 68.75 11.63 799.56 8.00 550.00 249.56 606.0031 STEEL BEAM (THRIE BEAM) FOR BEAM GUARDRAIL, INCLUDING HARDWARE LF 108. 21.33 2,303.64 25.00 2,700.00 -396.36 15709 PAGE 2 A-BIDDER PS&E ----------------------- ----------------------- A-PS&E ITEM NO. ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY UNIT PRICE AMOUNT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT DIFFERENCE 606.120 BEAM GUARDRAIL (STANDARD SECTION-STEEL POST) LF 39,650. 15.58 617,747.00 15.00 594,750.00 22,997.00 606.12031 BEAM GUARDRAIL (THRIE BEAM-MODIFIED) INCLUDING TRANS SECT, STEEL POSTS LF 1,475. 24.14 35,606.50 35.00 51,625.00 -16,018.50 606.12831 BEAM GUARDRAIL (THRIE BEAM APPROACH RAIL INCL. TRANSITION SECTION) U 2. 2,706.00 5,412.00 2,500.00 5,000.00 412.00 606.12851 BEAM GUARDRAIL (BRIDGE APPROACH UNIT) U 2. 4,300.00 8,600.00 2,500.00 5,000.00 3,600.00 606.14542 BEAM GUARDRAIL (TERM. UNIT TYPE EAGRT 50 FT., STEEL POSTS) U 29. 1,856.00 53,824.00 2,000.00 58,000.00 -4,176.00 606.147 BEAM GUARDRAIL (TERMINAL UNIT TYPE G-2) U 29. 383.00 11,107.00 440.00 12,760.00 -1,653.00 606.14962 BEAM GUARDRAIL (TERMINAL UNIT TYPE E-2, STEEL POSTS) LF 302. 28.64 8,649.28 26.00 7,852.00 797.28 606.2120 DOUBLE-FACED STEEL BEAM GUARDRAIL (GALVANIZED), STEEL POSTS LF 150. 29.64 4,446.00 22.00 3,300.00 1,146.00 606.312 SINGLE FACED TRANSITION RAIL, STEEL POSTS U 3. 2,147.00 6,441.00 2,800.00 8,400.00 -1,959.00 606.412 CONCRETE BARRIER, DOUBLE- FACED, PRECAST LF 80. 84.00 6,720.00 150.00 12,000.00 -5,280.00 606.41211 TRANSTION MEDIAN CONCRETE BARRIER, PRECAST U 4. 2,205.00 8,820.00 1,800.00 7,200.00 1,620.00 609.5 RESET GRANITE CURB LF 720. 15.77 11,354.40 7.50 5,400.00 5,954.40 609.811 BITUMINOUS CURB, TYPE B (4" REVEAL) LF 1,150. 6.28 7,222.00 3.75 4,312.50 2,909.50 618.61 UNIFORMED OFFICERS WITH VEHICLE $ 1. 75,000.00 75,000.00 75,000.00 75,000.00 619.1 MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC U 1. 16,960.00 16,960.00 50,000.00 50,000.00 -33,040.00 619.63 TRUCK-MOUNTED IMPACT ATTENUATOR, TEST LEVEL 3 EA 1. 6,930.00 6,930.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 -3,070.00 621.2 RETROREFLECTIVE BEAM GUARDRAIL DELINEATOR EA 500. 3.55 1,775.00 4.00 2,000.00 -225.00 621.31 SINGLE DELINEATOR WITH POST EA 220. 26.00 5,720.00 32.00 7,040.00 -1,320.00 628.2 SAWED BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT LF 1,925. 2.63 5,062.75 2.00 3,850.00 1,212.75 645.531 SILT FENCE LF 22,750. 2.47 56,192.50 2.50 56,875.00 -682.50 646.41 TURF ESTABLISHMENT WITH MULCH, TACKIFIERS AND HUMUS SY 14,200. 4.12 58,504.00 2.50 35,500.00 23,004.00 678.2 IMPACT ATTENUATION DEVICE (TEST LEVEL 3) U 2. 25,658.00 51,316.00 20,000.00 40,000.00 11,316.00 678.201 IMPACT ATTENUATOR FOUNDATION PAD U 2. 2,363.00 4,726.00 1,500.00 3,000.00 1,726.00 692. MOBILIZATION U 1. 15,477.00 15,477.00 50,000.00 50,000.00 -34,523.00 699. MISCELLANEOUS TEMPORARY EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL $ 1. 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 15709 PAGE 3 A-BIDDER PS&E ----------------------- ----------------------- A-PS&E ITEM NO. ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY UNIT PRICE AMOUNT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT DIFFERENCE 1008.11 ALTERATIONS AND ADDITIONS AS NEEDED- UNANTICIPATED WORK $ 1. 15,000.00 15,000.00 15,000.00 15,000.00 1010.15 FUEL ADJUSTMENT $ 1. 20,000.00 20,000.00 20,000.00 20,000.00 $1,287,590.33 $1,348,579.50 -60,989.17